The I Like Girls That Drink Beer Songfacts Says. Toby Keith Penned This Uptempo Break-Up Song With His Frequent Collaborator Nashville Singer-Songwriter Bobby Pinson. The Cut Finds The Narrator Leaving A Hoity Toity Woman As He Prefers More Down To Earth Girls. "Hey I Find What I Want In A Honky Tonk " He Tells Us. "I Like Girls That Drink Beer." The Tune Combines The Themes Of Keith's 2003 Single "I Love This Bar" And 2007 Release "High Maintenance Woman."