Intelligent people have their own methods of tagging music. There can be more than one legitimately correct way to tag and artist or song. Just because you're an uptight moderator on a website that does not make you the god of mp3 tagging, and it is annoying and offensive to tell people they are doing things incorrectly when they are not.
For instance, licensed music in a video game (such as the Grand Theft Auto series) should be credited to the actual artist
続きを読む
Intelligent people have their own methods of tagging music. There can be more than one legitimately correct way to tag and artist or song. Just because you're an uptight moderator on a website that does not make you the god of mp3 tagging, and it is annoying and offensive to tell people they are doing things incorrectly when they are not.
For instance, licensed music in a video game (such as the Grand Theft Auto series) should be credited to the actual artist, but alternate audio, such as full radio station rips, commercials, and dialogue are probably best credited to the game title. People who speak English (or other languages that use the Roman Alphabet are not going to tag Japanese, Russian, etc artists using an alphabet that their keyboards do not support. It is ironic and hypocritical since editable wiki pages clearly state "Please write only in English on this page.
Tags should be kept clean, and obvious mistakes and misspellings should be fixed. Legitimately correct alternate ways of tagging items is acceptable, and moderators need to stop scolding users for things that aren't mistakes.
