There Are Multiple Artists Called Mystery Girls. 1 Mystery Girls Is A Garage Rock Band Formed In Green Bay Wisconsin . Members Are Matt Conger - Guitar ..Jordan Davis - Guitar ..Casey Grajek - Vocals ..Jamis Kipp - Drums ..Michael Zink - Bass. 2 Mystery Girls Were A Lo-Fi Garage Punk Band Active In The Late 1970s / Early 1980s. Featured On Stark Products "Household Shocks" Compilation. Members Bass Alan Patching Drums Peter Duffin Guitar David Friend Vocals Craig Coward